If you happen to stumble to this review accidentally throught the magic of the intarwebs, you’re probably aware already about the mixed reviews this game is getting. After playing through the game from beginning to end, I cannot disagree more with the negative reviews.
The most common complaint I’m reading is that the tasks are “repetitive.” You go to a town, climb a viewpoint or two, save a few citizens, eavesdrop, beat up somebody for information, pickpocket…kill a few guards…then assassinate…rinse and repeat for 9 times.
I don’t get it: THAT IS THE POINT OF THE GAME. By that definitiion, we have “Gears of War” that’s even more repetitive: kill some bad dudes…go to a different brown setting and kill more bad dudes. How come we don’t hear anyone bitching about that?
Now, I can’t say I blame those naysayers about the game: the sandbox design of the game makes it easy to dismiss the game. To really give justice to the game…you should really play through it, and not just make the minimum number of tasks to finish an assassination target.
–
Assassin’s Creed, in my opinion, boasts a number of features not found in a lot of games:
- FANTASTIC ANIMATION. I cannot stress enough that this game beats even Metal Gear Solid in terms of animation fluidity INCLUDING TRANSITION ANIMATIONS. Watching Altair run, fight, and scale buildings is a sight to behold: one is lead to believe, there is inertia and gravity in this game. Using Havoc certainly helped. 
- AMAZING DRAW DISTANCE. And with virtually no slowdown.
- GREAT SOUND and VOICE ACTING. Well, minus Kirsten Bell.
That being said, this game also has a LOT of problems:
- ATROCIOUS LOADING TIMES.
- CUT SCENES you can’t skip. This is stupid.
- BUGS, BUGS, and MORE BUGS. Through my entire game, it froze on the load screen 3 times. and twice the whole game just froze…prompting me to reset the PS3! Unacceptable
- No variety in saving the citizens. Same crap over and over…gets tedious…towards the end I just ignored them.
- CONFUSING STORY. Especially the ending.
In the end, this game is really good. And I’m looking forward to the sequels.
Score 9 out of 10.
Popularity: 11% [?]